Ask an Expert!
1-800-606-7879
1-800-606-7879
Charcoal vs. Wood BBQ Showdown
There ain’t much better than the smell of meat sizzling over an open flame on a crisp evening. Whether you’re out at the cabin, deep in the bush, or just kickin’ back in your own backyard, there’s a debate as old as time itself: charcoal or wood for BBQ?
Charcoal: Hot, Reliable, and That Classic Charred Taste
Charcoal barbecuing is like the old faithful of BBQ—it’s predictable, reliable, and easy to control. When you’re cooking up a big ol’ slab of brisket or a pile of ribs, it’s important to manage direct and indirect heat. With charcoal, you can create hot zones and cooler spots by stacking the coals, giving you precise control over your cook.
Charcoal also burns hotter for longer, making it perfect for getting that crispy sear on a thick-cut steak. And let’s not forget the best part—when the meat drips onto those hot coals, it sizzles up and releases flavorful steam, infusing your food with that bold, smoky, flame-licked taste we all know and love.
But charcoal’s not all sunshine and rainbows. It’s messy—you’ll get smoke and ash everywhere, and if you’re not careful, your flannel is gonna be permanently stained with soot. That said, it’s still affordable and easy to find, making it a go-to for weekend warriors and seasoned pros alike.
Charcoal BBQs for the Job:
🔥 The Big Green Egg – A kamado-style powerhouse that retains heat like a dream.
🔥 Kamado Joe – A rock-solid ceramic grill with serious durability.
🔥 Napoleon Classic Kettle – A Canadian classic for straightforward charcoal cooking.
Wood: Pure, Natural, and Loaded with Flavor
Now, if you wanna cook like the pioneers, wood is where it’s at. Wood-burning BBQ is as traditional as it gets, and the beauty of it is that different types of wood give you different flavors. You want a rich, deep taste? Go with hickory. Something a little sweeter? Applewood or cherry is the way to go. Love that bold smokiness? Mesquite will punch you right in the taste buds.
The big win here is purity—no additives, no fillers, just good ol’ Canadian hardwood. But don’t be fooled—wood ain’t easy to master. You gotta monitor the smoke level carefully because too much can make your food taste like you licked a campfire.
Wood also burns faster than charcoal, meaning you’re gonna be feeding your fire more often. And if you’re in a rush? Forget it. Wood takes its sweet time to heat up, so patience is key. But when done right? It’s next-level BBQ.
Wood-Fired Grills for the Job:
🔥 Oven Brothers – Canadian-made, durable, and built for serious fire cooking.
🔥 Gozney – Designed for both pizza and BBQ, these ovens hold heat like a champ.
🔥 Cowboy Cauldron – If you want to feel like a true mountain man, this open-fire setup is unbeatable.
Final Verdict: Which One’s Right for You?
If you want precision, high heat, and an easy-to-control cook, go with charcoal. It’s great for searing, slow cooking, and getting that signature BBQ char.
If you’re after pure flavor and don’t mind a challenge, wood is king. You’ll need to be hands-on, but the reward is a flavor-packed experience that just can’t be matched.
At the end of the day, both are worth mastering, and a real Canadian pitmaster knows when to use each. So, grab a cold one, fire up the BBQ, and let’s get cookin’!
Written by: Phylicia Burd